Children’s positive attitudes to school not only decline once they move from primary to secondary school but keep on falling two or three years after they make the transition, according to one of the largest-scale studies ever to look at the problem.
Researchers have long known that moving schools at age 11 causes problems for significant numbers of children. But the survey by GL Assessment, based on data from almost than 32,000 children in England and Wales, has found that the problems persist in Years 8 and 9 as well as Year 7.
While a whole host of factors come into play at this point in a child’s development – hormones, friendships, growing up, taking control – the transition to secondary school marks a significant change for students and it is at this point that we begin to see a notable decline in student attitudes.
The study, from the leading provider of formative assessments to UK schools, looked at children’s feelings about school and teachers as well as their attitudes to themselves as learners – their confidence, work ethic and how prepared they felt themselves to be, for instance.
It found that the biggest decreases in children’s positive attitudes were towards schools, teachers and attendance. The score for children who feel good about school declines from 94 per cent in Year 3 to 84 per cent in Year 9. Positive attitudes towards teachers fall from 93 to 84 per cent and towards attendance drops from 90 to 82 per cent over the same year groups. The biggest declines in all these factors occur after Year 7 and not before.
The proportion of children who think the rules in school are fair declines from 94 per cent in Year 3 to 86 per cent in Year 9. Those who say they are bored at school increases from 19 per cent in Year 3 to 32 per cent in Year 9. And the number of children who say they like their teacher falls 10 percentage points between Years 3 and 9. The fall isn’t precipitous, but that equates to some 70,000 students in each year group who have a much more negative perception of teachers.
Attendance, too, becomes more of an issue for children the older they become. The proportion of students who say they would rather be somewhere else than in school rises from a quarter (25 per cent) to a third (33 per cent) between Years 3 and 9.
Greg Watson, Chief Executive of GL Assessment, said the findings helped shed light on why so many children found the transition from primary to secondary difficult.
“Pupil attitudes to learning and school are crucial and we simply haven’t been paying them enough attention. We need to understand what happens to children’s confidence and self-perception as learners when they change schools and teachers and parents need to know what can be done to remedy any problems.”
The continued decline in children’s positive attitudes well into secondary was revealing, he said. “Parents and teachers won’t be surprised that significant numbers of children find the move to ‘big’ school difficult. But I suspect few of them will have realised just how long attitudinal problems can persist. That should worry us all.”
Some attitudinal factors are remarkably stable over time. Self-regard as a learner, for instance, is 76 per cent in Year 3 and remains at 76 per cent in Year 9. General work ethic is 85 per cent in Year 3 and only falls slightly to 84 per cent in Year 9.
And not all metrics show a decline. Contrary to received wisdom, students tend to respond well to the increased curriculum demands as they get older. In answer to the question, ‘Do you get anxious when you have to do new work?’ the percentage of children saying they do halved between Years 3 and 9, from 35 per cent to 18 per cent. While the proportion saying the work they have to do in class is too easy declines from 43 per cent in Year 3 to 14 per cent in Year 9.
Sir John Dunford, Chair of Whole Education and the National Pupil Premium Champion from 2013 to 2015, said: “Moving from one school to another is a stressful experience. There is the anxiety of moving to a much larger school; of having to find your own way round without getting lost; of being in classes where you will know few, if any, of the other children; of the presence of lots of much older children; of having more than ten teachers instead of one; of the demands of increased homework – and all this at an age when the complexities of personal development can weigh heavily.”
“Attitudes are a good predictor of engagement,” he adds. “If a pupil is engaged and positive about themselves and their learning, they are more likely to be successful. It is particularly important for primary and secondary schools to listen to the voice of their pupils during this time.”
The trends from this study are reflected at Wakefield City Academy, which sees a drop in students’ feelings about school from Year 7 to Year 9 while some attitudes, particularly students’ perceived learning capability, general work ethic and response to curriculum demands, remain stable.
Dan Styles, the Trust Improvement Partner at Wakefield Academies Trust, is very aware of these attitudinal fluctuations and the school has introduced a number of interventions to limit the dip as much as possible. “Attitudinal surveys have provided us with some excellent insights into our students’ feelings and opinions about school. Sometimes students who on the surface appear the most secure, resolute and resilient can be masking concerns that could affect their potential to achieve. Armed with attitudinal data, we can support these students specifically in areas of self-regard and dealing with stress.”
A free copy of the GL Assessment report Pupil Attitudes to Self and School is available at gl-assessment.co.uk/pupilattitudes from 12.01 am on Friday 16 September.
Notes to editors
The study is based on data from 31,873 children from Year 3 to Year 9 across England and Wales, compiled during the period May 2015 – May 2016. There were on average around 2,500 students in each of the primary years 3 to 6 and around 7,000 students in each of the secondary years 7 to 9. The data was extrapolated from GL Assessment’s Pupil Attitudes of Self and School (PASS) attitudinal survey.
PASS is an all-age attitudinal survey that provides a measurement of a pupil’s attitudes towards themselves as learners and their attitudes towards school, suitable for pupils aged 4 to 18+. PASS data has been standardised against a highly representative national sample of more than 600,000 respondents.
For further information
Mirkka Jokelainen addresses the question how can we ask students to demonstrate thinking skills and the ability to apply knowledge by ticking a box?
John Galloway discusses how we can identify and support girls with social, emotional and behavioural difficulties.